Skip to content

When can a Spanish company book and deduct for Corporation Tax the loss on a loan to a group company in insolvency proceedings?

Reviewed by Toni Faura · Last updated:

In short. For accounting purposes, the impairment of a receivable from a group company is recognised as soon as there is objective evidence of non-payment, at the latest when insolvency (concurso de acreedores) is declared. For tax purposes, as it is a related party, it is only deductible in the period at whose year-end the court has already opened the liquidation phase (art. 13.1 LIS); before that, a positive adjustment is made.

When a company holds a receivable (a loan or an unsecured trade debt) from another company in its group that is in Spanish insolvency proceedings (concurso de acreedores) and heading for liquidation, two moments must be distinguished: when the loss is recognised in the accounts, and when it becomes deductible for Spanish Corporation Tax (Impuesto sobre Sociedades). They need not coincide.

Accounting: when to recognise the impairment

Under recognition and measurement rule 9 of the Spanish General Accounting Plan (Plan General de Contabilidad), as amended by Royal Decree 1/2021, the carrying amount of the receivable must be written down, at least at year-end, whenever there is objective evidence that it will not be recovered in full. The debtor's insolvency is a clear example. This is not optional: if the evidence exists, the impairment is mandatory.

  • Before insolvency: if it was already known that the debtor was not viable, the impairment should have been booked then.
  • On the insolvency declaration: the evidence is clear, at the latest at that point.
  • On the liquidation order (auto de liquidación): the estimate is reviewed using the inventory and the insolvency administrator's report.

The amount is the difference between the carrying amount and the present value of what is realistically expected to be recovered. Claims by group companies usually rank unfavourably in Spanish insolvency. In a liquidation without sufficient assets, it is therefore common to impair 100% or close to it. If the order is issued after year-end but before the accounts are drawn up, the risk already existed at year-end and must be recognised in that financial year.

Corporation Tax: when it is deductible

Article 13.1 of Law 27/2014 on Corporation Tax (LIS) allows impairment of receivables where, when the tax accrues, the debtor has been declared insolvent. However, it excludes receivables from related parties, such as companies in the same group. The exception is where they are in insolvency and the court has opened the liquidation phase. Consequently:

  • A mere insolvency declaration is not enough to claim the deduction.
  • Both conditions must be met at the end of the tax period (31 December if it matches the calendar year).
  • Amounts booked earlier are added back to the taxable base through a positive adjustment, and later deducted through a negative adjustment in the period in which the requirement is met.

If the liquidation order is issued in January of the following year, the negative adjustment goes in that year's return, even if the accounting expense appears in the previous year's accounts. Furthermore, without a charge to the profit and loss account there is no deductible expense (art. 11.3 LIS). If booked late, care must be taken that it does not result in lower taxation and that the year concerned is not time-barred.

Other points to bear in mind

  • Final derecognition: when the right to collect is extinguished, usually on conclusion of the insolvency, the receivable is derecognised against the impairment already booked. There is no further tax effect unless something has been recovered.
  • Recoveries in the liquidation: any reversal of impairment is taxable in the period in which it occurs (art. 11.6 LIS).
  • Insolvency without liquidation: if proceedings end without liquidation being opened, the art. 13.1 LIS exception is not met. Even so, the Spanish Directorate-General for Taxation (Dirección General de Tributos) accepts deducting the loss when the receivable is derecognised on the debtor's dissolution.
  • 70% limit: it does not apply, as it concerns impairments of receivables from unrelated debtors.
  • Tax consolidation: if both companies are in the same tax group, the insolvent company leaves it, and pending eliminations must be reviewed.
  • Trade receivable: review promptly whether the VAT (IVA) taxable base can be adjusted, as the deadline is short.

The date of the order opening the liquidation is the key fact for determining in which year the loss is deductible.

Related service: Corporate taxation and annual accounts

Would you like us to look at your case?

I am interested

Related questions

← See all questions

Disclaimer. These questions and answers have been prepared based on specific cases which may not be of general application. If you would like personalised advice, please contact us, as the answers may not apply to your particular case and could lead to a detrimental result or one contrary to the law. The company accepts no liability for the content of these questions and answers, since any decision requires a tax study of each specific case.

The time has come to get to know each other

Contact us and we will get back to you within 24 hours